00:00/00:00
外链地址
https://www.eemp3.com/audiofile/f41fda06de6a698bc4bdbd62fe6cd9fd.mp3
点击复制
本字幕由TME AI技术生成
Listen to me
Very carefully in my friend killing show wont not bringing you pins peace was never option
Welcome back back screen crush im ryinary in the world of the x men
Mutants are regarded with fear
Suspicion
And even hatred theyre different
Their abilities are perceived as a threat mutn fes discrimination
Segregation
Even externation with muthemes are at the heart of almost every exman story
And they always lead to to the opposing ideals of professor x and magnedo one envisions are hopeful and peaceful coexistence with humans and mutants
Ants built on the rejection of violence
Ence the eembacement of equality
Its the greatest gift
We have to bear their pain without breaking
And its born from the most human bomb
Hope the other ones to build a world
Where mutins can be free and safe by any means necessary for magnedo
There is no option for peace between mutants and humanity
Humans will forever fear and reject mutants and that hate will lead to the extermination of this people because of this magnedo believes that any action heatakes protect mutis justified the extermination has oalready to be glooten make no mistake my brothers
They will draw a blood
Any question is where do you join my brother hood and fight
Or for the inevitable genocide
And this is the question really our mutants and humans destined into exterminate each other
Or can there be a peaceful resolution was magnedo wrghten as ideology and prophacy of the future
And if so does that justify his terrible crimes
So lets explore the exmen movies and see if mamagnedo was in fact right the answer maybe far more complicated and surprising
Than you think the war is still coming chilles
And i intend of fighted by any means necessary eric lenchers entire life is shaped by the hoiccost
Its in the asschwitz concentration camp
Where erik sees the worst of humanity
Witnessing the genocide of his people
The nacies used discrimination that allowed them to dehumanize the jewish people see them as subhumans
Creatures
Whom they can opress brutilize and mass murder
This is the evil that made ericcy humanity
And only one way the enemy of his people
Its just following orders
Ive been the mercy of man
Just following orders
Never again despite the parallels to racism homophobiand anttisyymtism have you tried not being a mutant
Mutants are not hated
Simply because they are different
They are feared because of their powers
So it leads to an unavoidable escalation
An inevitable conflict
The very first texman movie establishes this right away as senator robert kelly advocates tes the muton registration act using paranoia and dehumanization as elelly successfully presents the mutants as threats
So humanity must take drastic measures to protect itself the truth is that mutants are very real
And they are among us
We must know who they are and above all we must know what they can do
History has proved that all it takes is a charismatically year er to say the right words
The right right to inincite people against the common enemy
How easy it is then ds a form hateful and angry mobs on paper
There is a logic behind the muton registration act
There are mutants
That are actually a threats of the world
So they do need to be monitored after all not all mutins are victims
Sabor tooth for example relishes and violence and murder
But most humans dont differentiate between murder is mutins like sabor tooth and a heroic mutins
Such as bees for humans
That mutants are all the same
I think the american people deserve the right to decide
Whether they want their children to be in school with mutants to be taught by mutants
The mra is a way to target and segregate mutants
Mark them as different and turn the public on them
And with the influence of federal law
The government can control mutance rights and even their freedoms
Whats to prevent the government from arresting any mutand
They deem to be too dangerous
And how quickly can inspiral out of control
President could declare a state of emergency place
Every every muton in the country under arrest upon hearing kellys words
Magnedo could only interpret them in one way
This is another holicost in the making
Ive heard these arguments before
So magnedo took action a very drastic action
He built a machine that conturn humans in the muttand
He planned to use it on the worlds leaders
Yes
There is a case to be made that magnedo created a very dangerous escalation
His actions confirm to humanity
That that mutants are dangerous
So they must take drastic measures to protect themselves
It becomes an endless look
Where each side funes justification for more and more terrible actions
But magnedos motivations come from desperation to save his people
Why do none of you understand what im trying to do those people down there
They control our fate and the fate of every other mutant
He witnessed the genocide of the jewish people
But he was powererless to stop it but now hes one of the most powerful mutons in the world and hell be damned if he wont save his people from another genocide de
When the sycooby accords are introduced in captecas civil war
Steve rogers and some some other heroes rejected them believing the accords are wrong and will limit the heroes from protecting the world
We may not be perfect with the safest hands are still along they went as far as choose violence against those who enforce the accorts
If steve rogers is justified to defy the worlds
Governments isnt magnedo justified to rise against the government that seeks to force the registration act on his people
Hes out a lie
But hes right
The superhero world is filled with individuals who took action
Who made the choice to fight for what they believe in steve rogers chose to fight road war ti because there are membling down their lives
I got no right to do any west than that batman became a vigilanti to battle crime and corruption in his city and the ponisher kills criminals
Because for him anything short of that is a half measure
Only i do the one thing that you can
You hit him and they get back up
I hit him and they stay down its permanent
Now this is not to say that savier in the ex manmanter just twilling their thumbs
They are doing their best to protect mutants and humans alike
But they only act
When they must desperately trying to juggle the fragile balance between peace and violence
Not all of humans once mutant extermination
But all it takes is a few anthi
I
Mutton leaders
Such as kelly and william striker to serve as the match to this powder
Kkick x two makes the case for why magnedo was always right
It might also prove that zaviors approach actually puts mutand kind at a far greater risk
While charles was so determined to stop his old friend from starting a war with humanity
He was blind the fact that the war had started long ago
When william striker was abusing brainwashing and turning mutants into weapons 没的我的我们的这个
We was supsed to protect them
What were you and your own people
People in the after manufacfacturing the attack on the president ririer gained ined free hand to deal with mutence
With extreme prejudice
Ironically despite all of charles as talk about peaceful coexistence
He became the harbinjer of death for his people
If not for magnedo
Every mutton in the world would have died this makes magnedo this savor of mutton kind bozaviors way almost exterminated them
All it also proves that all it takes is one hateful human to be tangible threat to the entire
Muttrace one man
Man all took was one man
How can mutts be safe in a world
Where something like this can happen
Now does it look from that jobws its fighting ting the good fight from here
It doesnt look like that playing by your rules
Charles doesnt naive
He knows that humans are far from perfect
Yet he keeps believing in a better tomorrow to afault t
Because he simply cant accept the magnedo is right right so so mutts need magnedo hes not the hero they deserve
But the savior they need
Since his view of humanity is the very thing that saves a mutants in x too
And this is something that keeps happenthroughout the exmand franchcise
As well as the comics and magneto shows just look at what happened during the cuban missile crisis the x man saves a day
They prevent a role war three
But in doing
So they revealed themselves to the world
And what was humanitys first response rainfire on the mutants
If not from magnedo
Everyone on that beach would be dused
Just like magnedo predicted the night before show us
They wont be french ate a furis
And that fear will turn to hatred a decade later boliver transk use paranoid inciiting the government against the mutants
And that led to the creation of the sentenals machines
That are built for one purpose only identify mutants and exterminate them
And we saw the results of that in the dark future as the sentals brought the mumutins to near extinction again proving the zavor is incapable of preventing the inevitable humanity does this too us then theres the future resuw and logan
Where almost all the mutants were wiped out this time
Humanity used a bioengineered weapon
That prevented the propagation of the exxgene
Only she shows some respect mute you look at the man en wiped that you kind this didnt exterminate the mutings out right but slowly over time
And made them into a commodity
That human beings could on essenshow some resyour own ascissment
Essentially turning the mutant race into slaves
There were times in humanity attempt to resolve their conflict with mumutants more peacefully at least on paper the muton cure
And the last stand was created to neutralize mutins powers and turn them back into or regular humans
A way to suppress the mutton
To exgenme accomic at a cure
Such a nice gesture
Right its basically humanity saying that being a mutant is like having a disease
The refliction is nothing more than a disease
A corruption of healthy cellular activity
Its hiypocritical and rooted in a warp sense of superiority
The cure is just another genocide
Attempt only in a different form unments are not sick humans
They are their own race carrying them is essentially the same as killing their individuality as a people you builbuilthese weweapons to destroy us
Why because you are afraid of our gifts
Because we are different humanity is always feared that which is different
And to make it clear
We hear a screen crush
You not can do in violence
In anyway
Were talking about magnedo is can we say the magnedo is right
Were talking king about his philosophy
And its justifiy will need to take action and protect his people
But in his battle for freedom
Magnedo committed a trocious crimes
He resorted to murder and terrorism
Those things should never be glorified and despite what he preaches
He has no problem using his own people as ponts and his revolution interest
And there are moments
Where magnedo became the very thinthat he hates we are the care
The caare of that inffamid perfect condition called homes saium
There is also another factor in magnetous philosophy
As he believes that mutants are genetically superior to humanity
This of course leads to a sense of superiority
Which many times allowed him to justify his most terrible actions
Never
Never
Anyone tell
Tell to
And that same sense of superiority
He does mirr r justistiation ation not is s used in wa war too that said there is merit it to magnedos philosophhy mutants are the next step of human evolution mumutation
It is the key to our evolution
It has enable us to evolve from a single cell organism into the dominant species on the planet
Magnedo is a product of society
All the tragedy in his life made him cruel and radical
It doesnt justify anything
But it does explain why he does
What he does
History is filled with bloody revolutions
There is no way around it magneita was fighting for the safety and freedom of his people
And like the man said price of freedom is high
Always has sbeen
And its the price im willing to pay and do
I think that charles saviors intensions are and good
Of course we all should aspire for peace and equality work for a better tomorrow
And learn how to peacefuly coexist with each other
Its a dream
We should all strive for and never give up on it
But we also cant deny reality
Where at times this dream is so rarely feasible
Look im sorry for all the gloomand doom
But you know its true saabors ideology is based on the belief
That all sides will strive and agree on peace commuters really depend on such a one sided hope
When they are existence is constantly in the balance are you really so naive
Has to think that they wont battle their own extinction
Or is it arrogance im sorry after tomorrow theyre going to turn on us
But youre blind did so sasavior in the movies and in the comics
Can be a real hyporit
He preaches peace
But he himself as resorted to taking drastic measures over the years
Like manipulating and even deleting ing memories of other mutins
The time time messed ge engragraze mine to imprison the dark phoenix
He created a contingency plans to neutralize and kill the xmen
And he was part of the morally questionable team
The illuminotic plus theres this line from from the darpphoenix
Its what just the means to enhend driven what end is that keeping us safe
Which sounds like something magneddo would say quality of that movie aside sayors s approach
And it is actually very interesting
It shows that he has doubts about his vision as long as the exmen play heroes
The world might forget about the fact
That their re mutants we only have a one bad day away from then starting to see us as the enemy again
So what we wear matching costings and smile and pictures
I make king king more price to pay for keeping the peace
I risking our people to save
There yes what the exmen themselves ves the questioning in the effetiveness of the professors ideals especially when they are the ones who pay the price for them
But alyou think you are youre ammutant the whole world out there is fuof people that hate and fear you
You know wasting in time trying to protect them
And on top of that charles himself doesnt live by what he preaches because he in the other x man tend to live in exclusion and the x mention away from the humans
And that place is far from being the safest place from mutants after being attacked
Constantly and destroyed many times in contrast magnedo is able to create multiple safe havens from mutants
Such as genotia
Aarooim m uutopithats really the corore place as motves to build world
Where mutins can truly live in peace and freedom a place
Where they are accepted and dont feel like out cas
Or they dont have to be afraid of who they are or for their safety though magnedoas perfect utopia has no place for humans
The iority here is that every time magnedo built nations from humans
Most dothem en chose to live under his rule preferring separation from humans
Most thousand public accusing a pois my hetes normal
Thats because it is normal
Here in fact
At a certain point in the comics about ninety five percent of the mutton population lives on genoia
Thats more than sixteen million mutants choosing the safety and freedom
Magnedo offered over zavierous coexistence with humanity
If thats not proof enough
The magnedo is right
Then i dont know what is then smart
Your dumb im right
Youre wrong
And its nothing you can do about it 呀
But genotia has a dark history before becoming a muton safe havment
It was ruled by humans who in slave mutons
Eventually the island was given to magneto
Where he built an only mutton nation genoshabecame a prosperous safe and happy place from mutants
But it was a short lived uuopa as as the sentenals attacked the island in one day
The sentenals killed more than sixteen million mutons
Sixteen million
It was a complete aniolation
Reducing the mutton population to under one million after through the stevastate in the event
Many mutons around the world embrace the phrase magnedo was right right irirony
The the gentitia
And so many other calamities like it could have been averted if only magnedo o and prossssor acts work together
Ther the veterment of muton kind
Instead of fighting each other 什么
This is proven by the newest comic book house of x
And this story is savior
Abandoned his dream for peaceful co existence with humans instead
He puts all his efforts into create the ultimate safe habin for his kind
He magnedo joined forces
And on the island of krocoa
They built a new utopia better than any other that came before they declare crackoa as the soveregn nation for all mutants and thanks to the island unique qualities
It becomes a global superpower
The mutants are safer than ever
Because this time magnedo onsaabor are working together
Even a pocalypse joins them at the end of the story and magneo and professor rex stand together as the mutton celebrate their new age of freedom
They know that sooner later humanity will come for them
Because they will never accept mutants
And they will never allow them to possess such power
So the two friends turn enemies turn friends again unite to protect their people against humanity
Its a bitter swedending but houseevacx
And so many other exment stories in the comics
The movies and the animated shows send a very clear and loud mass search
Magnedo was right right have lived in the shashadows and shame and fear
For too long come out join me together in a brotherood of our
Our kind new tomorto that stops today
And so what do you think about all this was magneta right could there be a world
Where mutants in humans find a way to coo exist or is war inevitable let me know in the comments below war at me on twitter
And if its your first time here be sher to subscribe and hit that bill for scream crrush im rinary